How much trouble would I be in if I painted my island like this...

Using products from here
http://www.caromalcolours.com. This specific color is called peppercorn.
Without my husband knowing (he's a firm believer that wood should
never be painted)?
The current island is oak. Not "golden" oak, a lighter oak, but still an oak.
I have just switched out all of the kitchen hardware (fine, except two that you can't see above my fridge) and am now thinking of other ways to update before I knock down the wall and put in a pantry, solid surface countertops and a snack bar.
Here are the worst case scenarios that I can think of -
a) I mess up and it looks hideous. Since I've used paint, I'll have to strip it and restain it. hmmm
b) I love it and will then want to redo the rest of the kitchen.
c) After I do it, I love it, but then hate it and get sick of it.
So then, here is my justification -
a) It's only the island, so it's best to tackle a smaller surface first.
b) Making them a color I want will be less than all new cabinets.
c) It will match my new appliances better. (When I get them.)
d) I'll have to get new stools to match the new color.
e) Notice the oak cabinets in the background? Ya.
f) That island is awesome.
What do you think? Yea or Nea?